ATMO/ECE  489/589
Midterm Exam Answers


2.    We are first supposed to determine the small ion concentration n given a particle concentration of 5000 cm-3 and the fact that the attachment loss term begins to dominate recombination loss starting at particle concentrations of 1000 cm-3.

About half the class dropped the recombination term from the small ion balance equation and solved the problem in the following way (this was the quick approach that I intended)Here are the details of that calculation.  Several students forgot that the q term in the equation for conductivity and the q in the small ion balance equation are not the same quantity. 


Note the final conductivity value is somewhat less that what we are used to (we used a value of 2 x 10-14 mhos/m on the first day of class).  This is presumably due to the high particle concentration and high particle attachment loss rate.

The other half of the class left the recomination term in the small ion balance equation and solved the resulting quadratic equation (the quadratic equation was solved in the notes from the review for the 2013 Midterm Exam).  The details of that somewhat more time consuming calculations are shown below.


Note the final result is very nearly the same as we obtained when neglecting the recombination loss term.

3.    Most students didn't attempt this question, but it's not too bad.



4.    This was a relatively quick problem to work out.  In the first part you were supposed to calculate the resistance between the ends of a 10 cm long piece of graphite.  You're given the resistivity which is a property of a given material.  The resistance depends on the shape of the material.



Would the resistance be different if you connected to opposite sides of the piece of graphite?  At first glance I would have said no, the electricity is flowing through the same total amount of resistive material.  But the mathematics shows otherwise



The resistance in this configuration is lower.  To get a physical picture of why this is the case you can imagine electrical current running through several resistors connected in series or in parallel.  It's the same total amount of resistive material but the total resistance in the two situations is different.




5.    The figure below shows the main features:



(1) is the main positive charge center.  The main negative charge center (2) is more of a layer that seems to always be found between -10 C and -30 C.  Smaller volumes of positive charge (the so called lower positive charge centers) are found at (3) in the figure below the main layer of negative charge. 

The Reynolds, Brook, Gourley non-inductive electrification process is capable of explaining all three of these features (the figure below comes from the Feb. 18 class).



Basically graupel particles (G in the figure) collide with smaller ice crystals (IC) in the presence of supercooled water droplets.  Usually the graupel will end up with negative charge and the ice crystal will be positively charged.  The smaller, lighter ice crystals are carried up toward the top of the thunderstorm.  At temperatures warmer than TR (but still below freezing) the polarities are reversed.  This is thought to be responsible for the lower positive charge centers. 
This process is also able to explain the inverted polarity thunderstorms (the cloud at upper right in the figure above) that sometimes are seen in strong storms in the Central Plains with high liquid water contents. 

The layers of charge found at the cloud boundaries (points (4) and (5) in the earlier figure), screening layers, form when currents flowing toward or away from the cloud encounter an abrupt change of conductivity at the edges of the cloud (much lower conductivities inside the cloud).

6.  We're given an expression for E(z) and first need to determine the value of zo


Then we will use the differential form of Gauss' law to determine the volume space charge density ρ(z)


The space charge has positive polarity.